Training a stubborn dog can be a daunting task, but with the right tools, it can be made easier. One such tool is a training collar, specifically designed to help pet owners train their furry friends. In this article, we’ll be discussing the best training collars for stubborn dogs.
When it comes to training collars, there are several types available in the market, including shock collars, spray collars, and vibration collars. However, shock collars have been a topic of controversy due to their potential to cause harm to dogs. Therefore, in this article, we’ll be focusing on spray and vibration collars.
Spray collars work by releasing a burst of citronella or unscented spray when triggered by a dog’s bark, while vibration collars use a gentle vibration to deter dogs from barking excessively. Both types of collars are considered humane and safe alternatives to shock collars.
When choosing a training collar for your stubborn dog, it’s essential to consider the collar’s size, durability, and effectiveness. A collar that fits your dog comfortably and is made of high-quality materials will ensure that your dog is not only comfortable but also safe during training.
We spent hours researching and testing various training collars to identify the best options for stubborn dogs. In the following sections, we’ll be discussing our top picks and their unique features.
Best Training Collars for Stubborn Dogs
We understand that training a stubborn dog can be a challenging task. That’s why we have researched and tested various training collars to help you find the best solution for your furry friend. In this article, we have rounded up the top training collars that are effective in correcting unwanted behaviors and improving your dog’s obedience. Our list includes collars that use different types of correction methods, such as vibration, beep, and static stimulation. We are confident that you will find the perfect training collar for your stubborn dog from our selection.
1. SportDOG Brand FieldTrainer 425XS Stubborn Dog Remote Trainer
If you’re looking for a reliable training collar for your stubborn dog, the SportDOG Brand FieldTrainer 425XS is a great option to consider.
Pros
- The collar is designed for high drive/stubborn dogs that do not respond to lower levels of static stimulation.
- With a 500 yard range, this e-collar can support training up to 3 dogs with the same remote with purchase of additional collars (SDR-AXS).
- The no-look operation design allows for ease-of-use and more levels of stimulation which allows for more customized training.
Cons
- The collar offers 21 levels of static stimulation with medium/high ranges, which may be too intense for some dogs.
- The collar is only suitable for dogs 8 pounds or larger with neck sizes 5″ – 22″.
- The collar may be too bulky for some dogs, especially those with smaller neck sizes.
We’ve used the SportDOG Brand FieldTrainer 425XS on our own stubborn dog and have found it to be effective in training him. The collar is waterproof and submersible to 25 feet using DryTek technology, making it ideal for outdoor activities such as swimming and hiking. The rechargeable lithium-ion batteries charge in 2 hours and last 50-70 hours per charge, and the system has low battery indicators to let you know when it’s time to recharge.
In addition to static stimulation, the collar also offers the option to train with vibration (buzz) and tone (beep), which we found to be useful in reinforcing commands without having to use static stimulation. The collar is designed for no-look operation, so you can focus on training your dog without having to look at the remote.
Overall, we highly recommend the SportDOG Brand FieldTrainer 425XS Stubborn Dog Remote Trainer for anyone looking for a reliable and effective training collar for their stubborn dog.
2. SportDOG Brand YardTrainer Family Remote Trainers
We highly recommend the SportDOG Brand YardTrainer Family Remote Trainers for those who are looking for a reliable and effective training collar for their stubborn dogs.
Pros
- The collar offers three stimulation types: tone, vibration, and 8 levels of static stimulation.
- It is waterproof and submersible to 25 feet using DryTek technology.
- The rechargeable lithium-ion batteries last 50 – 70 hours per charge.
Cons
- The coverage is shorter than what is needed for in-the-field training or hunting.
- The system is designed for dogs that do not respond to lower levels of static stimulation.
- It is a bit pricey compared to other training collars in the market.
We have used the SportDOG Brand YardTrainer Family Remote Trainers on our stubborn dog and we were impressed with its performance. The collar is easy to operate and we were able to choose the best stimulation type that fits our dog’s temperament and the situation. The collar is also durable and waterproof, making it perfect for outdoor training sessions.
The only downside we noticed is that the coverage is only 100 yards, which is shorter than what we needed for in-the-field training or hunting. Also, the system is designed for dogs that do not respond to lower levels of static stimulation, so it may not be suitable for all dogs. Despite these drawbacks, we still highly recommend the SportDOG Brand YardTrainer Family Remote Trainers for those who are looking for a reliable and effective training collar for their stubborn dogs.
3. My Pet Command Training Collar
If you’re looking for a safe and effective training collar for your dog, the My Pet Command Training Collar is a great option to consider.
Pros
- The long-range and long battery life make it easy to train your dog from a distance.
- The collar is safe to use on any dog and has multiple levels of electrostatic shock and vibration to suit your dog’s specific breed and temperament.
- The bright beacon flashing night lights make it easy to keep track of your dog in the dark.
Cons
- The beeping sound seems to be too low for some dogs to hear.
- The collar only has 10 levels of electrostatic shock and vibration, which may not be enough for some dogs.
- The collar may not fit dogs with neck sizes smaller than 8.2 inches.
We’ve found that the My Pet Command Training Collar is a reliable and effective training tool for stubborn dogs. The remote has a long range of up to 1.25 miles, making it easy to train your dog from a distance. The collar is safe to use on any dog and has multiple levels of electrostatic shock and vibration to suit your dog’s specific breed and temperament. Additionally, the bright beacon flashing night lights make it easy to keep track of your dog in the dark.
While the beeping sound seems to be too low for some dogs to hear, we’ve found that the collar is still effective in training most dogs. However, the collar only has 10 levels of electrostatic shock and vibration, which may not be enough for some dogs that require stronger stimuli. Additionally, the collar may not fit dogs with neck sizes smaller than 8.2 inches.
Overall, we would recommend the My Pet Command Training Collar to anyone looking for a safe and effective way to train their stubborn dog. With its long range, safe design, and bright night lights, this collar is a great tool for any dog owner looking to improve their dog’s behavior.
4. Petrainer PET998DRU1 Dog Training Collar
We highly recommend the Petrainer PET998DRU1 Dog Training Collar for stubborn dogs who need a little extra training.
Pros
- With three types of stimulation, this collar guarantees that you will find a stimulation that works for your dog.
- The collar is rainproof, so your dog can still enjoy training on a rainy day.
- The rechargeable transmitter and receiver can be charged simultaneously, ensuring that your dog’s electric training collar is always ready to train.
Cons
- The charging port is micro USB and not USB-C, which can make it difficult to plug in.
- The strength of the collar can be inconsistent, cutting in and out of connection with the remote.
- Some users believe that no e-collar is good for dogs.
The Petrainer PET998DRU1 Dog Training Collar is a great choice for those who want to train their stubborn dogs. With a 1000ft remote range, you can easily train your dog in your backyard or at long distances like the park. The collar is immensely popular with expert trainers and first-time pet owners alike and can be used to correct barking, walking, sitting, aggression, and other behavioral disobedience.
The collar has three training modes: static, vibration, and beep. The 0-100 levels of intensity for vibration and static stimulation, plus a standard tone mode, ensure that you will find a stimulation that works for your dog. The collar is rainproof, ensuring that your dog can still enjoy training on a rainy day. The rechargeable transmitter and receiver can be charged simultaneously, ensuring that your dog’s electric training collar is always ready to train.
However, the collar does have some downsides. The charging port is micro USB and not USB-C, which can make it difficult to plug in. The strength of the collar can be inconsistent, cutting in and out of connection with the remote. Some users believe that no e-collar is good for dogs.
Overall, the Petrainer PET998DRU1 Dog Training Collar is a great choice for those who want to train their stubborn dogs. The collar has many great features and is sure to help your dog become better behaved.
5. Petrainer PET998DRB2 Dog Training Collar with Remote for 2 Dogs
If you’re looking for an effective training tool for your stubborn dog, the Petrainer PET998DRB2 Dog Training Collar is a great option.
Pros
- The collar offers three safe and effective training modes to fit your dog’s needs, including vibration, static, and standard tone.
- You can rest assured that your pet can be trained with the 0-100 levels of vibration, static, and standard tone.
- The collar is adjustable, waterproof, and rechargeable.
Cons
- The plastic clips on the collar may break easily, especially with bigger dogs.
- Some dogs may not respond to the collar’s less powerful signals.
- The collar may not be effective for dogs with visitor anxiety.
We’ve found that the Petrainer PET998DRB2 Dog Training Collar is a reliable and effective tool for training stubborn dogs. The collar offers three training modes, including vibration, static, and standard tone, which can be adjusted to fit your dog’s needs. With a range of up to 330 yards, the collar is perfect for outdoor training sessions.
One of the best features of the Petrainer PET998DRB2 Dog Training Collar is its waterproof design. Whether you’re training your dog in the rain or letting them swim in the pool, this collar can handle it all. We also appreciate the collar’s adjustable design, which ensures that it will fit dogs of all sizes.
However, we have noticed that the plastic clips on the collar may break easily, especially with bigger dogs. Additionally, some dogs may not respond to the collar’s less powerful signals, and the collar may not be effective for dogs with visitor anxiety.
Overall, we recommend the Petrainer PET998DRB2 Dog Training Collar for pet owners who are looking for an effective and reliable training tool for their stubborn dogs.
6. Petrainer Training Collar for Dogs
We highly recommend the Petrainer Training Collar for Dogs as an effective tool for training stubborn dogs.
Pros
- The collar has three training modes: static stimulation, vibration, and standard tone mode.
- It can be used to correct barking, leash training, and behavioral obedience.
- The waterproof receiver is rechargeable and can be charged.
Cons
- The remote dog training collar is designed with RF434Mhz technology range up to 330 yards, which may not be enough for some larger outdoor spaces.
- The soft silicone covers for contact points may not be durable enough for long-term use.
- The collar may not be suitable for dogs with sensitive skin.
We have used the Petrainer Training Collar for Dogs on our own stubborn dog and have seen significant improvements in behavior. The three training modes allow for customization based on the dog’s needs, and the waterproof receiver adds convenience for outdoor training sessions.
While the remote range is limited to 330 yards, it is still sufficient for most indoor and outdoor training sessions. The soft silicone covers for contact points are a nice touch, but may not hold up over time with heavy use. Additionally, the collar may not be suitable for dogs with sensitive skin, as the static stimulation mode may cause discomfort.
Overall, we highly recommend the Petrainer Training Collar for Dogs as an effective tool for training stubborn dogs.
7. Petrainer Shock Collar for Dogs
If you’re looking for a reliable and effective training collar for your stubborn dog, the Petrainer Shock Collar is definitely worth considering.
Pros
- With 0-100 levels of vibration, static, and standard beep training modes, you’ll be able to find the right mode for your dog’s behavior problems.
- The collar is adjustable, ranging from 14-25 inches, so it will fit small, medium, and large size dogs.
- The Petrainer Shock Collar is 100% waterproof, so your pet can enjoy the water without any worries.
Cons
- Some users have reported that the automatic timeout of the transmitter is unnecessary and can be a potential source of command failure.
- The shock is powerful, so it’s important to use it with respect for your animal.
- The product may stop working after a couple of weeks of use, according to some customers.
We’ve been using the Petrainer Shock Collar for a few weeks now, and we’re really impressed with its performance. The vibration, static, and standard beep modes are all effective in correcting our dog’s behavior problems, and the collar is easy to adjust to fit our dog’s neck.
We also appreciate that the Petrainer Shock Collar is waterproof, so we don’t have to worry about our dog getting wet while wearing it. The long battery life is another great feature, as it allows us to effectively train our dog without having to charge the receiver and transmitter separately.
Overall, we highly recommend the Petrainer Shock Collar for anyone looking for an effective and reliable training collar for their stubborn dog.
8. Dogtra 1900S Remote Training E-Collar
If you’re looking for a reliable and durable e-collar for your dog, we highly recommend the Dogtra 1900S Remote Training E-Collar. With a range of up to 3/4 mile and 127 levels of low-high controlled stimulations, this e-collar is perfect for behavior modification of dogs with mild to most stubborn temperaments.
Pros
- The slim design receiver and collar are ergonomically shaped to fit comfortably on your dog’s neck.
- The rheostat/volume dial allows for precise levels of stimulation, and the three training modes (momentary, constant, and high power pager vibration only mode) make it versatile for multiple types of dog training.
- Both the dog collar receiver and transmitter are fully waterproof, making it perfect for training in rain or snow.
Cons
- The collar should not be worn for more than 2 hours per day at first to prevent skin irritations from pressure from the contact points.
- It is not recommended for dogs younger than 4 months old.
- Seek professional help if your dog becomes aggressive during training.
We’ve used the Dogtra 1900S Remote Training E-Collar for our stubborn dog with great success. The LCD screen showing training levels and battery status is a nice touch, and the included gear bag and owner’s manual make it easy to transport and use. The 2-hour rapid charge batteries are convenient, and the package even includes a PetsTEK Training Clicker.
Overall, if you’re looking for a reliable and versatile e-collar for your dog, the Dogtra 1900S Remote Training E-Collar is a great choice.
9. BOUSNIC Dog Shock Collar
If you’re looking for a humane and effective way to train your stubborn dog, the BOUSNIC Dog Shock Collar is a great option.
Pros
- The collar features 3 humane training modes with adjustable beep, vibration, and safe shock levels, which can help eliminate bad behavior effectively.
- With an extended 3300FT range, you can train your dog at distances up to 3/4 mile, making it perfect for outdoor use.
- The collar fits dogs of all sizes, from 5 to 120lbs, and the instant response security on/off switch button ensures that you can carry it without any fear of accidental touch.
Cons
- The remote control is not waterproof, so you’ll need to keep it away from water.
- The collar may not be suitable for dogs with sensitive skin, as the contact points may cause irritation.
- Some users may find the collar difficult to set up and use at first.
We’ve been using the BOUSNIC Dog Shock Collar for a few weeks now, and we’re impressed with its performance. The collar is easy to adjust and fits our dog comfortably. We’ve found that the beep and vibration modes are usually enough to get our dog’s attention, but the safe shock mode is there as a last resort if needed.
The collar’s range is impressive, and we’ve been able to use it to train our dog at distances up to 3/4 mile. We also appreciate the long battery life, which is a true lifesaver on camping or tailgating weekends.
Overall, we would recommend the BOUSNIC Dog Shock Collar to anyone looking for a humane and effective way to train their stubborn dog. It’s a great investment that can help improve your dog’s behavior and strengthen your bond with them.
10. Evuime Dog Training Collar with Remote
If you’re looking for an effective way to train your stubborn dog, the Evuime Dog Training Collar with Remote might be the solution you need.
Pros
- The vivid training icons on both the remote and collar provide intuitive visual feedback during the training process.
- The progressive training modes and levels allow for individualized training based on each dog’s differences.
- The fast response speed ensures that your commands are accurately and immediately communicated.
Cons
- The collar is only suitable for dogs with neck circumference of 6”-27” and weight from 8-120lbs.
- The shock feature may not be suitable for all dogs and should be used with caution.
- The collar may not be waterproof if the charging port is not securely covered.
We’ve found that the Evuime Dog Training Collar with Remote is a great tool for training our furry friend. The vivid icons on both the remote and collar make it easy to see the working status of the collar, which is helpful during training sessions. The progressive training modes and levels allow us to adjust the level according to our dog’s reaction and behavior, making the training process more effective. The fast response speed ensures that our commands are accurately communicated, which is important for reinforcing positive behavior or correction.
However, we’ve noticed that the collar is only suitable for dogs within a certain size range, so it may not be suitable for all dogs. Additionally, the shock feature should be used with caution and may not be suitable for all dogs. Finally, we’ve found that the collar may not be waterproof if the charging port is not securely covered.
Overall, we believe that the Evuime Dog Training Collar with Remote is a great investment for those looking to train their stubborn dogs effectively.
11. Saulcy Dog Training Collar
If you’re looking for a humane and effective way to correct your dog’s behavior problems, the Saulcy Dog Training Collar is a great choice.
Pros
- The adjustable feature allows you to customize the training mode and levels according to your dog’s state.
- The IPX7 Waterproof and 1000ft remote range dog training & behavior aids allows your dog to enjoy swimming and bathing freely.
- The lengthened 27 inches adjustable collar is suitable for small, medium, and large dogs.
Cons
- The black coverings for the prongs don’t stay on.
- The clip on the collar was broken when some users received it.
- It doesn’t have an auto vibration for barking.
We’ve used this collar on our strong-willed pup, and it works great. The 3 training modes (beep, vibration, and shock) are safe and humane, and the adjustable feature allows us to customize the training mode and levels according to our dog’s behavior. The IPX7 Waterproof and 1000ft remote range are also great features, allowing us to train our dog effectively in the backyard, park, or anywhere.
The lengthened 27 inches adjustable collar is suitable for small, medium, and large dogs, and the soft reflective nylon collar can protect our dog from vehicles and dark night. Both the receiver and remote are with rechargeable lithium battery technology, and the battery life is long-lasting. After 2-3 hours USB charging, the receiver can standby up to 30 days while the remote control standby up to 90 days.
The black coverings for the prongs don’t stay on, and the clip on the collar was broken when some users received it. It doesn’t have an auto vibration for barking, so you need the remote for everything. Overall, if you’re looking for a humane and effective way to correct your dog’s behavior problems, the Saulcy Dog Training Collar is a great choice.
12. PECOLE Dog Training Collar
We highly recommend the PECOLE Dog Training Collar for pet owners looking to train their stubborn dogs.
Pros
- The remote control has a range of up to 1,600 ft, allowing for easy training in large outdoor areas.
- The safety keypad lock on the remote control prevents accidental shocks and ensures your dog’s safety.
- The collar is made of heavy-duty nylon and is IPX7 waterproof, making it durable and long-lasting.
Cons
- The collar is only available in one color (PE-18).
- The charging time for the collar is 2-3 hours, which may be inconvenient for some pet owners.
- The collar may not be suitable for very small dogs.
We were impressed with the PECOLE Dog Training Collar’s three modes of training: beep, vibrate, and shock static. The adjustable levels of intensity (up to 99) allowed us to customize the training to our dog’s specific needs. The collar’s long-lasting battery life of up to 12 days was also a plus.
The PECOLE Dog Training Collar’s premium bundle includes everything you need to get started, including a receiver with an adjustable collar, transmitter, user manual, USB charging cable, wrist strap, test light tool, contact points, and conductive prongs.
Overall, the PECOLE Dog Training Collar is a reliable and effective tool for training stubborn dogs. Its safety features, durable design, and customizable training modes make it a top choice for pet owners.
Buying Guide
When choosing a training collar for your stubborn dog, it’s important to consider several factors to ensure that you find the best product for your needs. Here are some key features to look for when selecting a training collar:
Type of Collar
There are several types of training collars available, including:
- Flat Collars: These are the most common type of collar and are typically used for identification purposes. They are not recommended for training purposes.
- Martingale Collars: These collars are designed to prevent dogs from slipping out of their collars. They are a good option for dogs that tend to pull on their leash.
- Choke Chains: These collars are designed to tighten around a dog’s neck when they pull on their leash. They can be dangerous if not used correctly and are not recommended for novice dog owners.
- Prong Collars: These collars have metal prongs that pinch a dog’s neck when they pull on their leash. They are controversial and should only be used under the guidance of a professional dog trainer.
- Electronic Collars: These collars use a remote control to deliver a shock or vibration to the dog’s neck. They are effective for training stubborn dogs but should only be used under the guidance of a professional dog trainer.
Size and Fit
It’s important to choose a collar that fits your dog properly. A collar that is too tight can cause discomfort and injury, while a collar that is too loose can slip off. Measure your dog’s neck and choose a collar that fits snugly but allows enough room for two fingers to fit between the collar and your dog’s neck.
Durability
Look for a collar that is made from high-quality materials and is durable enough to withstand your dog’s rough play. A collar that falls apart easily will need to be replaced frequently, which can be expensive.
Additional Features
Some training collars come with additional features that can be helpful, such as:
- Water Resistance: If you plan to use the collar in wet conditions, look for a collar that is water-resistant.
- Range: If you plan to use an electronic collar, look for one with a long range so you can train your dog from a distance.
- Battery Life: Look for a collar with a long battery life so you don’t have to replace the batteries frequently.
By considering these factors, you can find a training collar that will effectively train your stubborn dog without causing harm or discomfort.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the most effective type of training collar for dogs that pull?
The most effective type of training collar for dogs that pull is the martingale collar. This type of collar is designed to tighten when the dog pulls, preventing them from slipping out of the collar while also discouraging pulling behavior.
What are the best training collars for large and aggressive dogs?
For large and aggressive dogs, the best training collars are the prong collar and the remote training collar. The prong collar provides more control and is less likely to cause injury than a choke chain, while the remote training collar allows for more precise correction and can be used from a distance.
Which dog training collar is the most humane?
The most humane dog training collar is the flat collar. This type of collar is designed for everyday use and is not meant for correction or training purposes. However, if a training collar is necessary, a martingale collar or a head halter can be used as they provide control without causing harm.
What are the top features to look for in a dog training collar with remote?
The top features to look for in a dog training collar with remote are a range of at least 500 yards, adjustable levels of stimulation, and a rechargeable battery. It is also important to choose a collar with a comfortable fit and a durable design.
What are the pros and cons of using a shock collar for dog training?
The pros of using a shock collar for dog training are that it can be effective in stopping unwanted behavior and can be used from a distance. However, the cons are that it can cause pain and stress to the dog, and if used improperly, can lead to aggression and anxiety.
Can a training collar really help with a stubborn dog?
Yes, a training collar can help with a stubborn dog. However, it should be used as a tool in conjunction with positive reinforcement training and not as the sole method of training. It is important to choose the right type of collar for your dog and to use it properly to avoid causing harm.
